The New York Times Book Review - Marilyn Stasio
…the trouble with historical crimes is that the ingenuity of the perpetrators can overshadow the humanity of their victims. In that context, The Woman on the Windowsill: A Tale of Mystery in Several Parts, by Sylvia Sellers-Garcia, serves as a grim but effective corrective.
From the Publisher
The book deftly ranges across Italian iconography, Maya cosmovision, casta paintings, Enlightenment urbanism, conceptions of death, masculinity, gender violence, crime and punishment, and the growth of the state.”—Laura Matthew, Hispanic American Historical Review“With transparency and integrity, this tour-de-force exhibits the historian’s craft even as it sometimes blurs lines between nonfiction and fiction. . . . Engaging prose, astute analysis. . . . Remarkable.”—David Carey Jr., Journal of Modern HistoryReceived honorable mention for the Louis Gottschalk PrizeWinner of the James P. Hanlan Book Prize, sponsored by the New England Historical AssociationWinner of the Bolton-Johnson Prize, sponsored by the Conference on Latin American History“The Woman on the Windowsill is that rare history book that will keep you on the edge of your seat. At the book’s core is the paired drama of an unfolding crime with the historian’s measured discovery of a puzzling and at times inscrutable past.”— Kris Lane, Tulane University“An exquisite book. It is at once scholarly and popular, learned and accessible, challenging and inviting. The beauty is in the understated elegance, the pacing, and the care with which Sellers-Garciá approaches the pleasures and the problems of the archive.”— Raymond Craib, Cornell University“Every historian dreams about finding a spellbinding old case or an irresistible cache of documents. Sellers-García has found such a case and used it to give us a grand tour of colonial Guatemala City, showing us its cobblestone streets, nearby ravines, hospitals and medical procedures, families from various walks of life, city leaders, victims, and villains.”—Andrés Reséndez, author of The Other Slavery: The Uncovered Story of Indian Enslavement in America