Older is the album that many observers initially believed
Listen Without Prejudice, Vol. 1 to be -- a relentlessly serious affair,
George Michael's bid for artistic credibility. It's an album that makes
Listen Without Prejudice sound like
Faith.
Michael has dispensed with the catchy, frothy
dance-pop numbers that brought him fame, concentrating on stately, pretentious
ballads -- even
"Fastlove," the album's one
dance track, lacks the carefree spark of his earlier work. Although
Michael's skills as a
pop craftsman still shine through -- several songs are well-constructed
ballads that rank with his best material -- his earnestness sinks the album. It is one thing to be mature and another to be boring. Too often,
Michael mistakes slight melodies for mature craftsmanship and
Older never quite recovers. When melodies do pop up, he doesn't deliver them with enough force to make an impact, and the album slowly disappears as a result. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine