Modern Hatreds: The Symbolic Politics of Ethnic War

by Stuart J. Kaufman

Overview

Ethnic conflict has been the driving force of wars all over the world, yet it remains an enigma. What is it about ethnicity that breaks countries apart and drives people to acts of savage violence against their lifelong neighbors?

Stuart Kaufman rejects the notion of permanent "ancient hatreds" as the answer. Dissatisfied as well with a purely rationalist explanation, he finds the roots of ethnic violence in myths and symbols, the stories ethnic groups tell about who they are. Ethnic wars, Kaufman argues, result from the politics of these myths and symbols—appeals to flags and faded glories that aim to stir emotions rather than to address interests. Popular hostility based on these myths impels groups to follow extremist leaders invoking such emotion-laden ethnic symbols. If ethnic domination becomes their goal, ethnic war is the likely result.

Kaufman examines contemporary ethnic wars in the Caucasus and southeastern Europe. Drawing on information from a variety of sources, including visits to the regions and dozens of personal interviews, he demonstrates that diplomacy and economic incentives are not enough to prevent or end ethnic wars. The key to real conflict resolution is peacebuilding—the often-overlooked effort by nongovernmental organizations to change hostile attitudes at both the elite and the grassroots levels.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780801487361
Publisher:	Cornell University Press
Publication date:	05/31/2001
Series:	Cornell Studies in Security Affairs
Edition description:	New Edition
Pages:	280
Sales rank:	963,262
Product dimensions:	6.12(w) x 9.25(h) x 0.75(d)
Age Range:	18 Years

About the Author

Stuart Kaufman is Professor of Political Science and International Relations at the University of Delaware.

Table of Contents

1. Stories about Ethnic War

2. The Symbolic Politics of Ethnic War

3. Karabagh and the Fears of Minorities

4. Georgia and the Fears of Majorities

5. Elite Conspiracy in Moldova's Civil War

6. Government Jingoism and the Fall of Yugoslavia

7. The Power of Symbols

Notes
Index

What People are Saying About This

Robert J. Kaiser

In Modern Hatreds, Stuart Kaufman provides a solid, cohesive argument in favor of paying more attention to the myths and symbols underlying ethnic conflict. The systematic treatment of ethnic conflict across comparable case studies distinguishes this study from most other recently published works on this topic. This is not only a sound piece of scholarship, but also an accessibly written book that should be read in and beyond academe.

Editorial Reviews

While providing excellent background of ethnic wars, Modern Hatreds is not simply a historical text. It offers a modern interpretation of the many recent individual conflicts, and helps knit together the broader themes that are relevant to them all.

National Journal

Convincing in arguing that ethnic violence is not the result of 'ancient hatreds,' and that contemporary politics and the struggle for power among individuals and elite groups largely determine who will engage in violence and who, ultimately, will get killed.

New York Review of Books

Modern Hatreds is an excellent and timely contribution to scholarship on ethnic war.... Kaufman manages to combine a thoroughly researched and detailed analysis of the case studies and the construction of a hypothesis that may explain, to some extent, the emergence of ethnic war.

-- "Journal of International Studies"

Convincing in arguing that ethnic violence is not the result of 'ancient hatreds, ' and that contemporary politics and the struggle for power among individuals and elite groups largely determine who will engage in violence and who, ultimately, will get killed.

-- "New York Review of Books"

This detailed work on the history of hatred provides a thoughtful perspective of events and motivations that should fascinate any serious reader.

-- "Political Science Quarterly"

While providing excellent background of ethnic wars, Modern Hatreds is not simply a historical text. It offers a modern interpretation of the many recent individual conflicts, and helps knit together the broader themes that are relevant to them all.

-- "National Journal"

From the Publisher

"In Modern Hatreds, Stuart Kaufman provides a solid, cohesive argument in favor of paying more attention to the myths and symbols underlying ethnic conflict. The systematic treatment of ethnic conflict across comparable case studies distinguishes this study from most other recently published works on this topic. This is not only a sound piece of scholarship, but also an accessibly written book that should be read in and beyond academe."

Robert J. Kaiser

"This detailed work on the history of hatred provides a thoughtful perspective of events and motivations that should fascinate any serious reader."

Political Science Quarterly

"Modern Hatreds is an excellent and timely contribution to scholarship on ethnic war.... Kaufman manages to combine a thoroughly researched and detailed analysis of the case studies and the construction of a hypothesis that may explain, to some extent, the emergence of ethnic war."

Journal of International Studies