Gambling with Armageddon: Nuclear Roulette from Hiroshima to the Cuban Missile Crisis

by Martin J. Sherwin

Overview

From the Pulitzer Prize-winning author of American Prometheus comes the first effort to set the Cuban Missile Crisis, with its potential for nuclear holocaust, in a wider historical narrative of the Cold War—how such a crisis arose, and why at the very last possible moment it didn't happen.

In this groundbreaking look at the Cuban Missile Crisis, Martin Sherwin not only gives us a riveting sometimes hour-by-hour explanation of the crisis itself, but also explores the origins, scope, and consequences of the evolving place of nuclear weapons in the post-World War II world. Mining new sources and materials, and going far beyond the scope of earlier works on this critical face-off between the United States and the Soviet Union—triggered when Khrushchev began installing missiles in Cuba at Castro's behest—Sherwin shows how this volatile event was an integral part of the wider Cold War and was a consequence of nuclear arms.

Gambling with Armageddon looks in particular at the original debate in the Truman Administration about using the Atomic Bomb; the way in which President Eisenhower relied on the threat of massive retaliation to project U.S. power in the early Cold War era; and how President Kennedy, though unprepared to deal with the Bay of Pigs debacle, came of age during the Cuban Missile Crisis. Here too is a clarifying picture of what was going on in Khrushchev's Soviet Union.

Martin Sherwin has spent his career in the study of nuclear weapons and how they have shaped our world. Gambling with Armegeddon is an outstanding capstone to his work thus far.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780307266880
Publisher:	Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group
Publication date:	10/13/2020
Pages:	624
Sales rank:	456,474
Product dimensions:	6.30(w) x 9.30(h) x 1.70(d)

About the Author

MARTIN J. SHERWIN, was University Professor of History at George Mason University and the author of A World Destroyed: Hiroshima and Its Legacies, winner of the Stuart L. Bernath and the American History Book prizes, and the coauthor, with Kai Bird, of American Prometheus: The Triumph and Tragedy of J. Robert Oppenheimer, which won the Pulitzer Prize for biography in 2006 as well as the National Book Critics Circle Award and the Duff Cooper Prize. He died in 2021.

Read an Excerpt

Prologue
 
In October 1962 I was a junior officer in the U.S. Navy attached to Patrol Squadron 31, an antisubmarine warfare (ASW) training unit based at North Island Naval Air Station. This was California, but from the prime San Diego real estate we inhabited, we looked across to “Florida,” the elegant Hotel del Coronado, where Marilyn Mon­roe, Tony Curtis, and Jack Lemmon had ushered in the sixties with the film Some Like It Hot.
 
1
 
Despite my modest rank—I was the squadron’s air intelligence officer—my responsibilities made me the custodian of our top-secret documents: our deployment orders in the event of war. Those orders were periodically updated, and when they were, a senior staff officer from Fleet Headquarters, always accompanied by an armed marine, arrived with a sealed envelope. A ritual followed: I signed for the new envelope, and he signed for the envelope that I removed from my top-secret safe, a miniature vault embedded in my large office safe. Except on these occasions, this inner sanctum was never unlocked. I had no expectation of ever learning what was in those envelopes (clippings from the New York Times, we joked), since they would be opened only in the event of a national emergency.
 
On a date in mid-October that I cannot recall, I was informed by telephone that a new envelope would arrive at an appointed time. This was soon after I received the disappointing news that an around-the-world flight I was scheduled to co-navigate for an admiral was cancelled. Within days all leaves were revoked. According to ru mors at our local hangout, the Mexican Village, the cause was rising ten­sions in Berlin.
Although we were on the West Coast, a sense of being engaged in an international crisis permeated my squadron’s ranks. Extra muni­tions, and weapons we had never before stored, were delivered to our hangars. Friends at El Toro, the Marine Corps Air Station north of San Diego, told me that marines in full battle gear were being flown east aboard military air transports. Something important was hap­pening, and we were going to be part of it.
 
On Monday, October 22, before President Kennedy informed the world that he had ordered Cuba blockaded, I was directed to retrieve the top-secret plans from my safe and deliver them—with the obligatory armed marine escort—to my commanding officer. Our squadron’s senior staff—the captain, the executive officer, and the operations officer—had assembled in the captain’s office to review the war plans. My recollection is that we would deploy to an airfield in Baja California, Mexico. The rationale was to disperse military aircraft beyond the reach of Soviet missiles. Some junior officers—all of us bachelors—joked that the beaches of Baja “would be a delight­ful place to die.”
 
I did not know until I researched this book how close to death we had come.

2

A world away from Coronado, California, another junior officer, stationed at a strategic rocket facility nine hundred miles east of Moscow, opened an envelope not very different from the one I had delivered to my squadron’s senior officers.
 
Valery Yarynich, who was exactly my age, had a different reac­tion to what he read. A junior officer and communications special­ist, stationed at division headquarters in Kirov, his unit was the central command center for five intercontinental missile battalions. After President Kennedy’s October 22 speech demanding that the Soviet Union remove its missiles from Cuba, Yarynich was deployed to a missile base in Siberia to help supervise command and control communications.
 
“At the peak of the confrontation,” he told the American journal­ist David Hoffman, he received a message containing the code-word “BRONTOZAVR.” That was the combat-alert go code—the dreaded signal to open the top-secret communications envelopes and transi­tion the R-7 liquid-fueled intercontinental ballistic missiles to war readiness. “I cannot forget,” Yarynich recalled, “the mixture of ner­vousness, surprise and pain on the faces of each operator, without exception—officers, enlisted men, women telephone operators.”
 
The unthinkable moment had arrived: Nuclear war was a mere press of a button away.
 
It was the most devastating war in world history. The estimated number of North American deaths was upwards of 200 million. Double, perhaps even quadruple that number of Soviet, Eastern European, and Chinese citizens perished, and no one had any reliable data on how many West­ern Europeans, Africans, Asians, South Pacific Islanders, and others the radioactive fallout killed as it circumnavigated the globe. Cuba became a wasteland, and there were few structures left standing in Moscow and Washington, DC.
 
It was an unthinkable war, but not an unimagined one. In 1957 the Australian writer Nevile Shute described its denouement in his eerily tranquil apocalyptic novel On the Beach. Adapted for the screen by John Paxton and directed by Stanley Kramer, in 1959 On the Beach premiered simultaneously in major U.S. cities and Moscow, to reports of viewers sobbing as Gregory Peck, Ava Gardner, Fred Astaire, and Anthony Perkins stoically prepared in Australia, where the movie is set, for the arrival of deadly radioactive clouds carrying the fallout from the nuclear war recently fought in the Northern Hemisphere. They were the last survivors of the human race, going quietly into endless night.
 
 
3
 
But the Cuban missile crisis did not replicate On the Beach, leaving thoughts of a Cuban missile war to pass into history. While partici­pants in (and historians of) the crisis never tire of recalling its details and dangers, the majority of the generation that lived through it, and subsequent generations, never became emotionally engaged with its potential consequences. It was neither Vietnam nor Watergate—nor Dallas, Texas, on November 22, 1963.

It was just the most devastating event in world history . . . that somehow didn’t happen.
 
That somehow is the subject of this book.

Table of Contents

Prologue xiii

1 A Reflection on Luck in History 3

2 World War III Was About to Begin 5

3 "We Will Die, but We Will Sink Them All" 11

4 Capt. Vasily Alexandrovich Arkhipov 22

5 The Long Cuban Missile Crisis, 1945-1962 29

Book I The Making of the Nuclear Age, 1945-1962

Part 1 Truman and Stalin

6 "This Is the Greatest Thing in History" 44

7 "The Secret of the Atomic Bomb Might Be Hard to Keep" 55

8 "Our Momentary Superiority" 64

Part 2 Eisenhower, Khrushchev, Castro, and the "Weapon of Mass Destruction"

9 "We Face a Battle to Extinction" 76

10 "An Extraordinary Departure" 86

11 "There Is Not Communists … but Cubanists" 93

12 "General Disarmament Is the Most Important" 107

13 "We Cannot Let the Present Government There Go On" 122

Part 3 Kennedy Khrushchev, Castro, and the Bay of Pigs

14 "Eisenhower Is Going to Escape" 132

15 "AES Wholly Disapproves of the Project" 146

16 "Cuba Might Become a Sino-Soviet Bloc Missile Base" 160

17 "It Will Be a Cold Winter" 167

Book II The Thirteen Days, October 16-28, 1962

Part 4 Khrushchev's Missiles

18 "What If We Put Our Nuclear Missiles in Cuba?" 182

19 "Without Our Help Cuba Will Be Destroyed" 193

Part 5 October 16 (Tuesday), Day One

20 "They're There" 204

21 "Actions Were Begun on October 3 to Prepare for Military Action Against Cuba" 215

22 "Bomb the Missiles; Invade Cuba" 222

23 "I'll Tell My Big Brother on You" 236

24 "Negotiation and Sanity, Always" 241

25 "Last Month I Should Have Said That We Don't Care" 247

Part 6 October 17 (Wednesday)-October 12 (Monday)

26 "Possible Courses of Action and Unanswered Questions" 258

27 "What Action Lessens the Chance of a Nuclear Exchange?" 266

28 "Flipping a Coin as to Whether You End Up with World War or Not" 277

29 The Chief Confronts the Chiefs 287

30 "Pull the Group Together!" 296

31 "I Trust that You Will Support Me" 301

32 "Nuclear War That Week Certainly Was Not Excluded from His Mind" 309

33 "What's EDP?" 316

Part 7 October 22 (Monday)-October 26 (Friday)

34 "We May Have the War in the Next Twenty-Four Hours" 326

35 "Kennedy Sleeps with a Wooden Knife" 337

36 "A Game Which We Don't Know the Ending Of" 344

37 "The Mobs Turned Up in London Instead of Havana" 353

38 "You Would Have Been Impeached" 359

39 "We Are Trying to Convey a Political Message … Not Start a War" 361

40 "A Russian Submarine-Almost Anything but That" 372

41 "Events Have Gone Too Far" 383

42 "Trade Them Out or Take Them Out" 393

43 "Time Is Very Urgent" 403

Part 8 October 27 (Saturday)-October 28 (Sunday)

44 "Let Us Take Measures to Untie That Knot" 410

45 "Liquidate the Bases in Turkey and We Win" 416

46 "To Any Rational Man It Will Look Like a Very Fair Trade" 419

47 "Attacking Sunday or Monday" 423

48 "We're Going to Have to Take Our Weapons Out of Turkey" 426

49 "An Act of Legitimate Defense" 437

50 "There Is Very Little Time to Resolve This Issue" 440

51 "You Got Us into This, Now You Get Us Out" 449

52 "I Thought It Was My Last Meal" 453

53 "We Have Ordered Our Officers to Stop Building Bases" 456

Part 9 Lies and Legacies

54 "Most of Them Did Not Like Adlai" 460

55 "It Ain't Necessarily So…" 465

Notes 471

Bibliography 553

Acknowledgments 571

Index 577

Editorial Reviews

★ 07/06/2020

Blunders, misunderstandings, and “dumb luck” shape history in this captivating reevaluation of post-WWII nuclear brinksmanship. Examining America’s use of atomic weaponry to contain Soviet expansion in Asia and the Americas, Pulitzer winner Sherwin (coauthor, American Prometheus) relates in nerve-jangling detail how presidents Truman, Eisenhower, and Kennedy grappled with their Soviet counterparts, Stalin and Khrushchev. According to Sherwin’s portrayal, Truman was “intellectually and emotionally unprepared” to understand the atomic high stakes and often deferred to his hawkish secretary of state, James F. Byrnes. Entangled in an affair with a White House intern, Kennedy wavered during the Cuban Missile Crisis and depended on his brother, Robert, to back-channel with the Soviets to avoid nuclear war. According to Sherwin, military personnel countermanded orders to launch nuclear weapons on multiple occasions during the two-week confrontation. In one instance, a U.S. missile squadron on Okinawa was poised to fire 32 nuclear missiles at targets in China and the Soviet Union before deciding to stand down. Intricately detailed, vividly written, and nearly Tolstoyan in scope, Sherwin’s account reveals just how close the Cold War came to boiling over. History buffs will be enthralled. (Sept.)

Publishers Weekly

In this riveting book, Sherwin provides a fresh and thrilling account of the Cuban Missile Crisis and also puts it into historical perspective. With great new material, he shows the effect of nuclear arms on global affairs, starting with the decision to bomb Hiroshima. It is a fascinating work of history that is very relevant to today’s politics.” —Walter Isaacson, author of Leonardo da Vinci

“A thrilling account of the tension-filled days when the world teetered on the edge of nuclear apocalypse. Drawing on new sources, Martin Sherwin shows how the Cuban missile crisis grew out of the nuclear sabre-rattling of the Cold War, going all the way back to the early confrontations between Truman and Stalin. No one is better equipped to tell this story than Sherwin, who has devoted his life to thinking about Armageddon, as witnessed by his ground-breaking biography of Robert Oppenheimer. A splendid accomplishment and a great read!” —Michael Dobbs, author of One Minute to Midnight: Kennedy, Khrushchev, and Castro on the Brink of Nuclear War
 
“A fresh examination of the Cuban missile crisis and its wider historical context, showing how the U.S. avoided nuclear war . . . Makes it clear how national leaders bumbled through the crisis, avoiding nuclear Armageddon through modest amounts of wisdom mixed with plenty of machismo, delusions, and serendipity . . . A fearfully convincing case that avoiding nuclear war ‘is contingent on the world’s dwindling reservoir of good luck.’” —Kirkus Reviews (starred review)

"Gambling with Armageddon will have a powerful and lasting impact because it does things that no other study does in an area that could not be more significant. Sherwin makes clear that the Cuban missile crisis was not really an aberration but an unsurprising outcome of the history and psychology world leaders brought to the weapons. We also learn how much mere chance—good luck—saved us from world-ending catastrophe. Sherwin has written a book that matters deeply, and has made an elegantly convincing argument for the abolition of nuclear weapons." —Robert Jay Lifton, author of Losing Reality

“This is what happens when one of the pioneers of nuclear history—one who researches broadly, thinks deeply, and writes beautifully—comes to grips with the most dangerous moment in human history. The result gives us a new understanding of the Cuban Missile Crisis in the broader context of the nuclear age and reminds us, even decades later, how dangerous our nuclear arsenals remain. Gambling with Armageddon is essential reading.” —Philip Nash, author of The Other Missiles of October: Eisenhower, Kennedy, and the Jupiters, 1957-1963

“Martin Sherwin’s beautiful account shows how the crisis grew out of the brinkmanship of the Cold War. He brings to life the main characters and examines with a marvelous combination of empathy and a critical intelligence, the decisions that Kennedy and Khrushchev faced and the choices they made. This is by far the best book on the crisis and a book of great relevance for today.” —David Holloway, author of Stalin and the Bomb

“It is difficult to believe that there is something fresh to say about the Cuban Missile Crisis. But Martin Sherwin has accomplished this feat. By meticulously reconstructing the decision-making process of October 1962 and placing the crisis fully in the context of Cold War atomic diplomacy he enables us to understand how the world came to the brink of destruction, how unprepared political and military leaders were for the crisis, and how level-headed officials rejected the fantasies of would-be warriors and drew back from disaster. And all this is presented with drama, eloquence, and even humor.” —Eric Foner, author of The Second Founding

“People describe ‘news you can use.’ Well, here’s ‘history you can use.’ Who knew that events 58 years ago could so resonate with events today? And, no doubt, tomorrow. I've read countless tomes on the Cuban Missile Crisis, and wrangled about it personally with Fidel Castro in 1994. But no one has, or could, recite and re-interpret those terrifying days as well as Martin Sherwin. In a nutshell, this is a marvelous book—riveting, revealing, quite remarkable. I stand awed by the scholarship, and the beautiful writing. Though Dr. Sherwin and I differ ideologically (by alot!), I find this book totally fair, and beautifully balanced. So read the book, and you, too, will be educated, entertained, and inspired.” —Kenneth Adelman, Reagan Arms Control Director and author of Reagan at Reykjavik

"Martin Sherwin has set the standard for writing the history of the ultimate weapons, the atomic and nuclear bombs. This book, his magnum opus, exploits U.S., Russian, and other recently opened documents to give the 1945 to early 1962 background, and the potentially cataclysmic debates and diplomatic exchanges of the Cuban missile crisis itself. That crisis continues to be the historical reference point for our current debates about the possibility of nuclear war. The 1962 events produced sleepless nights for Americans, and so can reading this book about how close the Americans and Russians came to creating nuclear winter on earth." —Walter LaFeber, Andrew H. and James S. Tisch Distinguished University Professor, Emeritus, Cornell University

"A page-turning account . . . Offers a masterful reinterpretation of the first decades of the Cold War. Switching perspectives gracefully between American and Soviet officials, going up and down the ranks from statesmen to second lieutenants, Sherwin distills decades of reading, writing, and thinking into a chilling, persuasive—and suspenseful—book." —David C. Engerman, Leitner Profressor, Department of History, Yale University

“Gambling with Armageddon puts the Cuban Missile Crisis in the proper historical context of the Cold War. Thoroughly researched, and relying on Russian, Cuban, and American sources, it makes a convincing case that only plain dumb luck saved the world back in 1962. A historical tour de force with important lessons for the next, impending nuclear arms race.” —Gregg Herken, author of Brotherhood of the Bomb: The Tangled Lives and Loyalties of Robert Oppenheimer, Ernest Lawrence, and Edward Teller

“Martin Sherwin is one of the great historians of the nuclear age . . . Through a vivid and definitive retelling of the Cuban Missile Crisis, based on the latest declassified sources, Sherwin explores how hundreds of millions of lives could easily have been lost. The implications of the story are inescapable." —Eric Schlosser, author of Command and Control: Nuclear Weapons, the Damascus Accident, and the Illusion of Safety
  
“Brilliant, powerful and terrifying, Sherwin’s book on the Cuban Missile crisis highlights how close we came to blowing up our planet, how fortunate we were that Kennedy and Khrushchev managed to save us, and how critical it is to have prescient leaders.” —William H. Chafe, Alice Mary Baldwin Professor of History, Emeritus, Duke University

"Gambling with armageddon offers a precious, powerful and detailed historical examination of the limits of leaders' control over nuclear crises and the role of luck in their outcomes. Examining the first seventeen years of the nuclear age and shedding new light on the Cuban Missile Crisis, it teaches scholars and citizens alike that our tendency to fall for retrospective illusions of control and understanding is inadequate, dangerous and that the leaders of the time were not exempt from them. It also masterfully demonstrates that factors beyond control can and should be studied. This has profound implications for scholarship and policy.” —Benoît Pelopidas, founding director of the Nuclear Knowledges program, SciencesPo, Centre de Recherches Internationales

“Not only does this book offer a new and thrilling day-by-day account of the Cuban missile crisis, but it also places it in the wider perspective of the preceding nuclear arms race. Written with verve and style, Gambling with Armageddon switches the dramatic action from the Oval Office of Kennedy’s White House, to the heart of Khrushchev’s Politburo in Moscow, then to the cockpit of US U-2 flights over Cuba, and to the stifling confines of the nuclear-armed Soviet submarines patrolling the Caribbean Sea. Provocative in tone and sweeping in scope, this is a book worthy of the seminal crisis of the nuclear age.” —Matthew Jones, Professor of History, London School of Economics 

“A blow-by-blow account of the most dangerous crisis of the nuclear age, which incorporates all the latest archival findings and weaves them together into a masterful, gripping narrative. Above all, Marty Sherwin offers a deeply original, and profoundly disquieting, interpretation of the Cuban missile crisis.” —Leopoldo Nuti, Professor of History of International Relations, Roma Tre University

“A thrilling read . . . This book takes us as close as we will ever get to the people whose judgments or insights determined the fate of 200 million people in a nuclear war.” —Thomas Leonard, Professor of History of Journalism, Emeritus, and Librarian, University of California, Berkeley
 
“A great achievement that should generate intense discussion not only about what now appears to be the dim past, but also about the kinds of people we now entrust our survival to . . . I found myself (almost) wondering if the world would in fact be destroyed, and was quite relieved when the answer was no . . . A remarkably good book in every way.” —Sanford Levinson, W. St. John Garwood and W. St. John Garwood, Jr. Centennial Chair in Law, University of Texas at Austin
 
“Evocative, compelling, interpretive . . . a tour de force. Sherwin makes the crisis so vivid. He clarifies beautifully what was happening meeting by meeting, what were the options, what were the ambiguities . . .  Far and away the best book on the crisis.” —Melvyn Leffler, Edward Stettinius Professor of History, Emeritus, University of Virginia

“A landmark work of history, transforming an all-too-familiar saga  into a gripping full account never seen before — one never more needed than today. Sherwin’s meticulous reading of the nuclear past can help rescue the human future. This is history that can save lives.” —James Carroll, author of House of War

“Who needs a VR (virtual reality) program to experience the heart-throbbing tension of the Cuban Missile Crisis when you can just read this amazing account by the preeminent nuclear historian of our era.  This is the most riveting book about our nuclear history that I have ever had the good fortune to read.  It transports the reader deep into the bowels of the US and Russian war-making machinery and captures the human emotions that animate one unexpected turn after another, and provides the larger context needed to put the drama in historical perspective.   It will change the way you think about how blundering into nuclear Armageddon was and is beyond human control.  As long as these weapons exist on earth, human destiny will depend on history’s roll of the dice.” —Bruce Blair, author of The Logic of Accidental Nuclear War

"Brilliant . . . Shows that leaders such as Kennedy, Khrushchev and Castro were stymied and constrained—often without even realizing it—by events beyond their control and by the faulty logic of nuclear strategy. In gripping chapter after gripping chapter, Sherwin makes abundantly clear the countless ways that things could have gone terribly wrong, but somehow did not. We are left wondering whether we can count on being so lucky the next time the world stands on the brink of Armageddon." —Ethan M. Pollock, Profressor of History and Slavic Studies, Brown University

"A magisterial historical reckoning, Martin Sherwin’s Gambling with Armageddon details the 'long Cuban Missile Crisis' from 1945 to 1962. Applying the extensive knowledge and scholarship acquired in almost six decades of exploring the perils of nuclear weapons, Sherwin casts an astute eye on the fallible leaders who avoided mass destruction through luck and belated recognition of the need to avoid the world-destroying consequences of nuclear war." —Dolores Janiewski, Profressor of American History, Victoria University, New Zealand

"Seventy-five years after the end of WW II with the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and thirty years after the end of the Cold War, fears of a nuclear apocalypse have largely faded away. Martin Sherwin’ s compelling book reminds us that the world remains in peril from a nuclear holocaust. His book is a wake up call to people everywhere that no one can be trusted with these weapons of mass destruction. It is a reminder of novelist Jules Romaine’s observation that WWI made clear that men can be made to do anything!" —Robert Dallek, Professor of History, Emeritus, UCLA

"Uncovers the shocking, nail-biting history of how close we came to nuclear war in the years between 1945 and 1962, and how a combination of chance, luck, accident and decision-making averted a catastrophe. In vivid and dramatic prose, Martin Sherwin tells what happened behind the scenes in the halls of power in the Soviet Union and the United States, under water in Soviet and US submarines, and in the thoughts and conversations of those who held the fate of the world in their grasp." —Elaine Tyler May, Regents Professor of American Studies, University of Minnesota

"Written in a style tat reminds one of 'Seven Days in May,' Martin Sherwin shows how atomic weapons shaped American foreign policy before and during the Cuban missile crisis.  He gives us the story of Kennedy's hour-by-hour changing attitude during critical Ex-Comm debates, and documents for the first time the key role Adlai Stevenson played in influencing the president's decisions toward a diplomatic solution." —Lloyd Gardner, Charles and Mary Beard Professor of History, Emeritus, Rutgers University

“Prodigious research, terrific writing, wonderful vignettes. and clever images . . . The story is compelling from the very beginning, with Truman at Potsdam . . . Sherwin’s personal involvement is there in just the right dose and right tone.” —Janet Lowenthal, Tzedek DC

From the Publisher

★ 09/01/2020

Pulitzer Prize winner Sherwin (history, George Mason Univ.; with Kai Bird, American Prometheus) served as an intelligence naval officer during the Cuban Missile Crisis, October 16–28, 1962. This deeply researched account has a you-are-there feel, as he discusses the harrowing 13 days when world devastation was only a mistake away. Earlier accounts and TV dramas frequently portray the crisis as an endgame between President John F. Kennedy and Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev. Sherwin dispels this simplistic interpretation by placing the crisis in its Cold War context, identifying its roots within the anti-Soviet and massive retaliation polices of the Truman and Eisenhower administrations. The book reveals West Berlin's importance to Kennedy and Khrushchev, identifies the roles played by National Security Adviser McGeorge Bundy, Secretary of State Dean Rusk, Cuban Prime Minister Fidel Castro, and UN Secretary-General U Thant. Additionally, Sherwin deftly shows how war was almost precipitated by a junior United States officer and avoided by a Soviet officer. Politician and diplomat Adlai Stevenson, the unsung hero, resolutely called for the blockade strategy ultimately adopted by Kennedy. VERDICT This important investigation of a significant Cold War event will inform and engross modern history readers.—Karl Helicher, formerly with Upper Merion Twp. Lib., King of Prussia, PA

Library Journal

★ 2020-06-06
A fresh examination of the Cuban missile crisis and its wider historical context, showing how the U.S. avoided nuclear war.

As Pulitzer Prize–winning historian Sherwin writes, it wasn’t due to wise national leadership. In 1945, dazzled at being sole possessor of the atomic bomb, American leaders debated its role. According to the author, Harry Truman and his advisers concluded that it was the key to containing Stalin. But Stalin was not cowed, and the confrontation evolved into the Cold War. Matters came to a head in 1959, when Fidel Castro overthrew Cuba’s dictator, obsessing the Eisenhower administration during its last year and Kennedy’s throughout. After taking office, Kennedy learned that U.S.–recruited anti-Castro Cubans were training to invade Cuba. To his everlasting regret, he assumed that officials in charge knew what they were doing. When the invasion was clearly failing, advisers expected Kennedy to send in American troops to prevent an international humiliation. That Kennedy chose humiliation was a mark of statesmanship but also a painful lesson about trusting experts. Castro and Soviet premier Nikita Khrushchev assumed that America would try again, and, angered by U.S. missiles in nearby Turkey, Khrushchev decided that putting missiles in Cuba would balance matters. Sherwin comprehensively recounts events during October 1962, after U.S. reconnaissance discovered the missiles. Everyone, Kennedy included, assumed that this meant war. American nuclear forces were alerted, and two decisions to launch were averted at the last moment. The first to propose negotiation was U.N. ambassador Adlai Stevenson. More than most scholars—and Kennedy himself—Sherwin gives Stevenson credit for planting the idea. Most readers know that, in the end, Khrushchev withdrew the missiles, and the U.S. removed theirs from Turkey. Sherwin’s detailed, opinionated scholarship makes it clear how national leaders bumbled through the crisis, avoiding nuclear Armageddon through modest amounts of wisdom mixed with plenty of machismo, delusions, and serendipity. Future crises are inevitable, and the author clearly demonstrates how there are no guarantees they will turn out so well.

A fearfully convincing case that avoiding nuclear war “is contingent on the world’s dwindling reservoir of good luck.

Kirkus Reviews